Wednesday, March 3, 2010

The Nation Hijacked By Nerds

The Red Sox will finish the 2010 season in third place and miss the playoffs.  Wait a minute. What’s wrong with me?  Has the cruel, cold world really made me into such a jaded person that I have such low expectations for the team I live and die by?  My entire life I have entered every season with the same childlike optimism when the first players start to work out down in Fort Myers.  (Nomar would take us to the promised land in 1999!  Carl Everett was sure to turn things around in 2001!  Carlos Baerga’s cheerleading would will us into the playoffs in 2002!).  ESPN has been getting on the stats nerd wagon as of late claiming the Red Sox are a better team than they were last year and will make the playoffs.  While I have often conceded the division to the Yankees (with the faint hope half their roster would land on the 60-day DL), never have I felt so helpless to the impending crush of pinstripes.  What has caused this aberrant feeling of impending mediocrity?  Let me get this out of the way – I hate the signings of John Lackey, Mike Cameron, and especially Adrian Beltre. 

First Lackey.  After the Sox faced him almost annually in playoff situations, I now understand the hatred Yankee and Angels fans have towards Josh Beckett.  The sneer.  The grouchy attitude on the mound.  A wicked curveball.  The similarities are stunning.  In fact baseball-reference.com says the pitcher most similar to Lackey in all of baseball history – is Josh Beckett.  But what is an unsettling separation between Lackey and Beckett is the fact that Lackey has only cracked 15 wins ONCE in his entire career.  There is also the concern that Lackey’s best days are behind him after five straight seasons not missing a start and then two straight seasons with injuries (albeit minor ones).  Lackey is also in the top five for most innings pitched in the last five years.  Yes, Lackey is a workhorse, but to sign a 31-year-old pitcher wit so many innings under his belt to a five-year deal raises an eyebrow or two.

My least favorite signing is that of Adrian Beltre.  The Mariners were probably the biggest dupes in history when they signed both Beltre and hitless wonder Richie Sexson prior to the 2005 season.  What followed were five long cantankerous seasons.  The report on Beltre is that he has a good personality and will be a good addition to the clubhouse.  Beltre’s numbers on the other hand suggest a player similar to the “I Play For Me” attitude of the ever aloof and despondent J.D. Drew.  Beltre comes with the ugly reminder of a player who never even sniffed 30 dingers OR 100 RBI OR a .300 average and, poof, just happens to lead the NL in 2004 with 48 home runs and hit .334 in his contract year, leading to his atrociously huge payday from the M’s (coughsteroidscough).  Since then?  Beltre slipped back to the player he was, never cracking 26 dingers with a .266 average in his five seasons in Seattle.  One would hope that big green wall in left will motivate him to bounce back from his injury-laden and abysmal 2009 campaign.  Thankfully he’s likely a placeholder with a short contract until young or traded talent can come in

Finally we come to Mike Cameron.  This one was perhaps the most baffling because he seems like such an un-Theo Epstein type player.  He’s old.  He strikes out a LOT.  He’s not an on-base or OPS guy (.340/.788 lifetime).  Then I found out that Theo’s gone all “Revenge of the Nerds” on Red Sox Nation.  Epstein has always been a firm believer in building a team around cold, hard math.  He is always looking for a new “in-vogue” statistic to make his free agent acquisitions.  The last “new” stat he experimented with was OPS and that landed guys like Kevin Millar, Bill Mueller, and, oh, David Ortiz in 2003.  It was a genius move and now OPS is one of the most used stats in baseball.  But his latest statistic is all kinds of wacky.

“Ultimate Zone Rating” was invented by a guy named Mitchel Lichtman fairly recently and has to be the most complicated baseball statistic I’ve ever seen.  Why would anybody take the time to split the field into 78 different “slices” and go through every ball hit to a player over the course of a season and see how they fielded them?  Why else would they then compare those hundreds, perhaps thousands of plays against every other player in the league that plays that same position?  Because they’re nerds, that’s why.  So I said, “OK math nerds, you can have your fun.”  Cameron is indeed a top-tier fielder when using UZR.  The most straightforward explanation is that a good fielder has a positive number for UZR and bad fielder has a negative one.  Cameron’s lifetime UZR is +39.  I’m going to take their word that +39 is very good (considering Jacoby Ellsbury is -16.4 lifetime - whatever that means).

But there’s one little snag when it comes to measuring defense – it’s a completely subjective science!  Math isn’t supposed to be subjective (unless we’re getting into Daniel Faraday island time travel territory and if a player reaches a UZR of +100 they turn into the Smoke Monster or whatever).  In all seriousness, the ability of a player to field a ball is completely up to the scorer of any given game.  Grounder right to you – yeah, you should make that play.  But do they get a negative point if they flub a grounder that hits a stray pebble?  It’s completely up to human opinion to decide if it’s an error or merits a notch down in their UZR.  It is a flawed statistic, yet Theo Epstein has built an entire team around this and other statistics like it.

Which brings me back to my original arguments – the Red Sox SHOULD have a good offense, but the Yankees WILL have a good offense.  There are too many question marks in the Red Sox lineup to enter this season with similar confidence as in past years.  As long as the Yankees reside in the AL East, offense reigns supreme and the Red Sox will always need another bat (Adrian Gonzalez?  AAAAAGH!  Sorry, it was really crowded on that bandwagon and I’m claustrophobic).  But I do have hope for this season – I hope I’m wrong.

(credit to baseball-reference.com, fangraphs.com, and blessyouboys.com for the UZR mumbo-jumbo)

No comments:

Post a Comment