
Theo Epstein is a numbers nerd. If you’re a Sox fan and you don’t know that by now, I don’t know what team you’ve been watching for the past seven seasons. When he became the general manager in 2003 he was a Moneyball disciple. He preached the benefits of the rarely regarded On-Base Percentage statistic and the unheard of OPS (On-Base Plus Slugging). Relying almost exclusively on numbers instead of the old-school baseball technique of “gut-feeling,” all Epstein did was construct a team that has made the playoffs in all but one year of his tenure and captured two World Series titles. He also drafted based on stats and now the Red Sox have one of the most admired farm systems in the game after a generation of ill-advised trades.
The Boston sports talk shows have been beside themselves as Theo let Jason Bay walk and signed John Lackey and 99-year old Mike Cameron. Most fans have been saying the same thing all winter – “Why did Belichick go for it on 4th and 2??” No, wait. They’re saying, “What is Theo thinking?” Well, Epstein, armed with the good faith of eradicating an 86-year title drought, is using the 2010 season as his latest science experiment. He’s dipping into the pool of little-known stats again and building a team around pitching and defense.
This is easily the biggest gamble of Epstein’s reign as general manager. It could even be bigger than trading Nomar. He has built a team using complex techno-babble stats like Plus-Minus, Runs Prevented, and Ultimate Zone Rating (which I think is the name of next month’s WWE pay-per-view special). Explaining these stats is so complicated, that would take another article (MLB.com has a good explanation). I’ve lived by the creed, “In Theo We Trust” since the Nomar trade worked, but even this seems a little hare-brained. Any other division in baseball and I would be behind him. The AL East is just simply a different beast. Defense wins championships in basketball and football, but baseball?
There hasn't been a team that truly won a title solely on pitching and defense since the deadball era (before 1920). Yes, the Red Sox’s pitching staf is stacked. But even if David Ortiz finds his old self, Kevin Youkilis has an MVP-caliber year, and J.D. Drew and Adrian Beltre suddenly can hit in pressure situations, the Sox better pray for a lot of one-run victories.
But this is the luxury Theo has – even if his experiment fails the Sox can easily win 85 games with some of the top prospects in the minors due for arrival in 2011. Obviously 85 wins is not a playoff team. In fact, the Yankees seem primed to snag the division quite handily again. But the most important question that nobody is asking is – what if Theo’s right again? The last time Epstein made this many off-season moves based on little-known stats and got this much grief from the fans, he signed some guy named David Ortiz. We’re all prepared for Theo to be wrong about defense being able to win the AL East. But what if he’s right? That would be weird.