Friday, January 15, 2010

Weird Science: The 2010 Red Sox


Theo Epstein is a numbers nerd. If you’re a Sox fan and you don’t know that by now, I don’t know what team you’ve been watching for the past seven seasons. When he became the general manager in 2003 he was a Moneyball disciple. He preached the benefits of the rarely regarded On-Base Percentage statistic and the unheard of OPS (On-Base Plus Slugging). Relying almost exclusively on numbers instead of the old-school baseball technique of “gut-feeling,” all Epstein did was construct a team that has made the playoffs in all but one year of his tenure and captured two World Series titles. He also drafted based on stats and now the Red Sox have one of the most admired farm systems in the game after a generation of ill-advised trades.

The Boston sports talk shows have been beside themselves as Theo let Jason Bay walk and signed John Lackey and 99-year old Mike Cameron. Most fans have been saying the same thing all winter – “Why did Belichick go for it on 4th and 2??” No, wait. They’re saying, “What is Theo thinking?” Well, Epstein, armed with the good faith of eradicating an 86-year title drought, is using the 2010 season as his latest science experiment. He’s dipping into the pool of little-known stats again and building a team around pitching and defense.

This is easily the biggest gamble of Epstein’s reign as general manager. It could even be bigger than trading Nomar. He has built a team using complex techno-babble stats like Plus-Minus, Runs Prevented, and Ultimate Zone Rating (which I think is the name of next month’s WWE pay-per-view special). Explaining these stats is so complicated, that would take another article (MLB.com has a good explanation). I’ve lived by the creed, “In Theo We Trust” since the Nomar trade worked, but even this seems a little hare-brained. Any other division in baseball and I would be behind him. The AL East is just simply a different beast. Defense wins championships in basketball and football, but baseball?

There hasn't been a team that truly won a title solely on pitching and defense since the deadball era (before 1920). Yes, the Red Sox’s pitching staf is stacked. But even if David Ortiz finds his old self, Kevin Youkilis has an MVP-caliber year, and J.D. Drew and Adrian Beltre suddenly can hit in pressure situations, the Sox better pray for a lot of one-run victories.

But this is the luxury Theo has – even if his experiment fails the Sox can easily win 85 games with some of the top prospects in the minors due for arrival in 2011. Obviously 85 wins is not a playoff team. In fact, the Yankees seem primed to snag the division quite handily again. But the most important question that nobody is asking is – what if Theo’s right again? The last time Epstein made this many off-season moves based on little-known stats and got this much grief from the fans, he signed some guy named David Ortiz. We’re all prepared for Theo to be wrong about defense being able to win the AL East. But what if he’s right? That would be weird.

An Evaluation of the Steroid Era in Baseball, Part 2

All of this brings me to my point: In a game so immersed and dependent on statistics and the record books, how can we evaluate this period against all the others? How can we possibly compare Mark McGwire and Roger Maris? What do we do with Bonds’ single season record? What do we do with stats in general? From Alex Rodriguez’s MVP years to even the mediocre stats like those of Arroyo, an asterisk simply won’t do in many cases. After David Ortiz’s name surfaced as being on the infamous 2003 list, a friend of mine suggested that the entire steroid era be wiped from the record books. In his eyes every stat, every record, every award, every World Series win from 1995 to 2003 was tainted. If performance-enhancing drugs were as widespread as it now seems, he may have a valid point.

However, there are players I truly believe (and hope) never took PED’s who deserve to have their stats in the record books. Sure Hall-of-Famers like Ken Griffey Jr., Frank Thomas (a 500 Club member and never hit higher than 43 dingers in a year – who knew?), Pedro Martinez, and Derek Jeter have managed to stay above steroid speculation. As much as I hate the Yankees and love the Red Sox, the news that would forever shatter my faith in baseball would be that Derek Jeter is a dirty player. There is perhaps no other player that epitomizes the spirit of the game like Number 2. There were players that didn’t need the juice to perform. Why take their accomplishments away? Then again, it’s hypocritical, callous, and downright impossible to put singular asterisks next to names in statistics books and the Hall of Fame.

So, I offer my solution: keep it all, but put the whole era in a big gray box. Let every kid that walks through the doors of Cooperstown know that from 1995 to 2003, the game was affected by this outbreak of drugs. A lot of players used them, some didn’t. They have their place in the history of the national pastime. The BBWA need to come down off their high horse on this issue. If we refuse entry to the steroid users, do we kick out every player that used a spitball? Do we sponge out every player before 1947 because some of the best players weren’t competing at the professional level because of the segregation of the game? Baseball is history. History is baseball. Some parts of history are hard to look at, but they can’t just be swept under the rug. For 9 seasons a lot of players used performance-enhancing drugs. Not everyone did it, but nobody spoke up about it. Nobody is innocent.

(Author’s Note: Of course this is all under the assumption that the new rules and stricter testing is actually working. Kind of a big assumption, I know.)

An Evaluation of the Steroid Era in Baseball, Part 1


So Mark McGwire admitted to using steroids and the debate begins again about the Hall of Fame credibility of such players. No one in baseball is guiltless when it comes to the stain of steroids. Every player or manager who put on a uniform after the strike until the stricter testing began in 2004 is at fault. Every general manager, owner, and agent is at fault. Commissioner Selig is at fault and Players Association head Donald Fehr is at fault. The media is at fault. And yes, the fans are at fault. Whether some encouraged steroid use, turned a blind eye, or were blissfully ignorant - it doesn’t matter. Those around the goings on of a baseball team every day can’t possibly stand with a clear conscience and say, “I had no idea.” How did it come to this? Why does the media explode and the world stand still when a big name surfaces under shady circumstances?

In 1995 baseball was in big trouble. The 1994 strike alienated millions of fans and the World Series was canceled for the first time in 90 years. Not even two world wars could stop the World Series before. Now greed had. When President Clinton finally forced baseball to get back to business the sport had lost millions of dollars and millions of fans. But we came back because everybody started hitting home runs.

Combined with Selig’s one saving grace of his tenure (the brilliant 3 division format with the Wild Card) it was a recipe for the return of baseball. In 1996 attendance almost returned to pre-strike numbers, just two years removed from the horrible affair. More teams could be competitive in the new format. Suddenly home run numbers spiked and that meant huge contracts. From there it simply spiraled out of control. Players would reach contract years and suddenly were able to jack 40 to 50 home runs when they had barely cracked 30 in previous years (most notably Brady Anderson’s 50 home run campaign in 1996 who then never sniffed 40 homers after that season). In 1995 not a single player made more than 10 million dollars. By the time the first testing began in 2003, the top 25 paid players in baseball made more than 10 million dollars. In the late 90’s baseball made like the dot-com boom and reached record profits off of inflated expectations.

Then what captured the imagination of the world is now viewed as a national tragedy. The home run race between Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa in 1998 was arguably the most thrilling single-season storyline in the history of the game. That summer was a celebration of baseball wrapped in such a vivid dichotomy - homer for homer, black and white, Cardinals and Cubs. It seemed like everybody in the country was tuned in to see McGwire break Roger Maris’ record. Maris’ daughter was there to hug him. Selig was there to shake his hand. Thinking about it now makes me sick. Then just three years later, the moment came where everyone stopped and said, “Wait a minute. What’s going on here?” Barry Bonds broke McGwire’s record of 70 home runs. Everyone was convinced McGwire’s record would stand for decades just as Maris’ had. How could it fall so quickly? Then the comparison pictures began to surface. How could Sosa be so skinny in his rookie year with the White Sox and so utterly humungous in a Cubs uniform? Why did Barry Bonds’ head seem to shrink from a Pirates uniform to a Giants one? If Bonds didn’t break McGwire’s record in 2001, it seems quite possible that the steroid rampage might not have been discovered.

Beyond steroids were undetectable human growth hormones, amphetamines, and even dietary supplements that were thought to be clean only to have been tainted with illegal substances as in the case of BALCO created supplements. A drug culture was allowed to thrive for at least nine seasons and it was rewarded with tens of millions of dollars. The super-contracts negotiated by the likes of Scott Boras and others only sweetened the prospect of using performance-enhancing drugs. Of course it was only a matter of time before kids in the minors would say, “Hey, maybe if I do it too, I’ll get a huge contract someday!” The obvious cases were McGwire, Bonds and Sosa whose bulging muscles and strained jerseys would be laughable now if it weren’t so damn sad. But it’s the recent admission of pitcher Bronson Arroyo using “Andro” that opens a whole new can of worms. Arroyo is as skinny as a rail. And Arroyo said he was taking PED’s? And on top of that, he wasn’t sure if it was tainted with steroids? If a player didn’t have to appear jacked out of his skin to be a candidate for PED use the question now became – who didn’t use steroids during that nine-season span?