Friday, January 15, 2010

An Evaluation of the Steroid Era in Baseball, Part 2

All of this brings me to my point: In a game so immersed and dependent on statistics and the record books, how can we evaluate this period against all the others? How can we possibly compare Mark McGwire and Roger Maris? What do we do with Bonds’ single season record? What do we do with stats in general? From Alex Rodriguez’s MVP years to even the mediocre stats like those of Arroyo, an asterisk simply won’t do in many cases. After David Ortiz’s name surfaced as being on the infamous 2003 list, a friend of mine suggested that the entire steroid era be wiped from the record books. In his eyes every stat, every record, every award, every World Series win from 1995 to 2003 was tainted. If performance-enhancing drugs were as widespread as it now seems, he may have a valid point.

However, there are players I truly believe (and hope) never took PED’s who deserve to have their stats in the record books. Sure Hall-of-Famers like Ken Griffey Jr., Frank Thomas (a 500 Club member and never hit higher than 43 dingers in a year – who knew?), Pedro Martinez, and Derek Jeter have managed to stay above steroid speculation. As much as I hate the Yankees and love the Red Sox, the news that would forever shatter my faith in baseball would be that Derek Jeter is a dirty player. There is perhaps no other player that epitomizes the spirit of the game like Number 2. There were players that didn’t need the juice to perform. Why take their accomplishments away? Then again, it’s hypocritical, callous, and downright impossible to put singular asterisks next to names in statistics books and the Hall of Fame.

So, I offer my solution: keep it all, but put the whole era in a big gray box. Let every kid that walks through the doors of Cooperstown know that from 1995 to 2003, the game was affected by this outbreak of drugs. A lot of players used them, some didn’t. They have their place in the history of the national pastime. The BBWA need to come down off their high horse on this issue. If we refuse entry to the steroid users, do we kick out every player that used a spitball? Do we sponge out every player before 1947 because some of the best players weren’t competing at the professional level because of the segregation of the game? Baseball is history. History is baseball. Some parts of history are hard to look at, but they can’t just be swept under the rug. For 9 seasons a lot of players used performance-enhancing drugs. Not everyone did it, but nobody spoke up about it. Nobody is innocent.

(Author’s Note: Of course this is all under the assumption that the new rules and stricter testing is actually working. Kind of a big assumption, I know.)

No comments:

Post a Comment