Friday, March 23, 2012

2012 NL East Predictions

The NL East might raise the most debate here. I'm refusing to get on a certain bandwagon this season after being burned by the "sexy" pick the last two years (see my 2010 AL West predictions...oy). I'm guessing not many people are picking the East to go this way, but damn it I'm standing by it.

2012 predictions in bold, 2011 record in italics

1. Atlanta Braves (92-70, 89-73)

Key Additions: None
Key Losses: Derek Lowe, Alex Gonzalez, Nate McLouth, George Sherrill

I don’t think the collapse of the Braves at the end of last season can really be put on the same level as Boston’s simply because not many people expected Atlanta to be in the hunt in the first place. What happened with the Braves was simply a lot of young players wearing down in the long season. Atlanta went to its bullpen more than any other team in baseball and the results was an ERA over 5.00 in September.

Interestingly enough, the Braves did absolutely nothing in the way of acquisitions this offseason. And why should they? This team is loaded with some of the best young players in baseball on offense and one of the most exciting young pitching staffs in recent memory. I have a serious man crush on this team, especially in the pitching department between Jair Jurrjens, Tommy Hanson, Brandon Beachy, Mike Minor in the rotation and Eric O’Flaherty, Jonny Venters and Craig Kimbrel in the bullpen.
The pitching is more than fine, but the offense needs to get off to a quicker start than last year. With Martin Prado healthy, Dan Uggla recharged after a super second half and a full season of Michael Bourn, the Braves will have the offensive pop they didn’t have last year.

BOTTOM LINE: With the hard lessons of 2011 burning in their minds, it will be the perfect motivation for the Braves to win it all in 2012.

2. Philadelphia Phillies (90-72, 102-60)

Key Additions: Jonathan Papelbon, Ty Wigginton, Jim Thome, Chad Qualls
Key Losses: Raul Ibañez, Roy Oswalt, Ryan Madson, Brad Lidge

A lot of what’s going on with the Phillies is very similar to what I said last year about them (which turned out to be pretty spot on – just sayin). The offense is full of injury-prone players whose health will make or break this team. Ryan Howard is out until at least late May, Placido Polanco is already dealing with injuries and Chase Utley is a stiff breeze away from knee problems. And is Jimmy Rollins really only 33? He plays like he’s pushing 40. This is a make or break year for J-Rolls to prove he still has it.

But who am I kidding? All you have to say is three names – Roy Halladay, Cliff Lee and Cole Hamels – to know that this team is still one of the best in the NL. So why the 12-win drop-off in my prediction? The NL East has once again become the most competitive in all of baseball. The young Braves have a year of experience under their belt and the Nats and Marlins made the biggest splashes of the off-season outside of Pujols and Prince to seriously contend.

BOTTOM LINE: The Phillies and three of its division rivals are going to pummel each other for a third of all their games and win totals are bound to take a hit.

3. Washington Nationals (87-75, 80-81)

Key Additions: Gio Gonzalez, Edwin Jackson, Brad Lidge, Mark DeRosa
Key Losses: Livan Hernandez

Whatever happens this season in Washington, you can’t blame them for trying. Since moving from Montreal to D.C. in 2005 the Nats have slowly but surely built a solid foundation for a competitive team. After some flashy moves last season that didn’t pan out much, Washington suddenly got very shrewd and beefed up its rotation and bullpen big time.

Of course nothing is going to energize this team more than the return of its young ace and supposed savior Stephen Strasburg after a year out of the game. His return in September was a huge encouragement and other über-prospect Bryce Harper is tearing the cover off the ball in spring and might provide some pop come mid-season. The key for the Nats will be offense and if Ryan Zimmerman can live up to his new, huge contract and lead this team. Zim might have a good season, but it’s not going to be enough to rub off on a pretty weak lineup.

BOTTOM LINE: Nice pitching staff, but I don’t think this lineup has enough power to crack the playoffs this year.

4. Miami Marlins (82-80, 72-90)

Key Additions: Jose Reyes, Heath Bell, Mark Buehrle, Carlos Zambrano
Key Losses: Javier Vazquez, Chris Volstad

Miami is of course going to be the sexy pick to make noise in the postseason with their huge off-season acquisitions and brand new ballpark. But much like their basketball brethren, the Heat, ego is going to derail this team. Between Hanley Ramirez, Reyes and new manager Ozzie Guillen – that’s enough Latin drama to script a telenovela on Univision.

The pitching staff is what is going to have to hold this team together in the event this offense comes apart (and it will). No other team is depending more on its ace than the Marlins. Josh Johnson NEEDS to stay healthy if the Fish want to have any chance of the postseason. Buehrle, if healthy, is going to have a renaissance moving to the NL. Amazingly, Buehrle has gone ELEVEN straight years with at least 30 starts and 200 innings pitched. Talk about a throwback to a bygone era of pitching. He’s a lock for 15 wins and would not be surprised if he can lower his ERA to the low 3’s, maybe even high 2’s. But nobody on this offense has been able to put together a consistent season in recent memory, including Reyes and his bogus 2011 batting title.

BOTTOM LINE: The offense and lots of ego will hold this team back. Too bad the Marlins missed out on Pujols.

5. New York Mets (69-93, 77-85)

Key Additions: Andres Torres, Frank Francisco, Jon Rauch, Ramon Ramirez
Key Losses: Jose Reyes, Chris Capuano

How can you hear the words “New York Mets” and not immediately shake your head with a wry smile and sigh with exasperation? The front office drama with this team is of epic proportions and it is going to handcuff the Mets for years to come.

The offense on this team is laughable and it doesn’t help that image when the Citi Field walls get moved in a few feet every year. Do we need to bring them in to Little League distance for the Mets to succeed? Supposed centerpiece David Wright continues his downward spiral and Jason Bay’s offensive collapse continues to mystify (seriously…the guy averaged 31 HR’s and 103 RBI for 5 years before he came to Queens). If Johan Santana ever decides he wants to pitch again the Mets’ staff could be the one bright spot of this team. The Mets did bring in three solid set-up/sometime closers in Francisco, Rauch and Ramirez making their bullpen the strongest part of this team. But that's not saying much.

BOTTOM LINE: Ownership/front office chaos, plus an offense in shambles, plus a much stronger division equals a last place finish for the Mets.

You're gonna hafta wait the weekend...my AL East predictions come Monday. Playoffs predictions and my opinion of the new second Wild Card will be posted Tuesday. Might have a couple more opinion pieces after that depending on my work schedule...

No comments:

Post a Comment