I listened. And I waited. And I kept waiting. The spark never came. The energy never came. The musicianship never came. And most shockingly of all – the album was entirely devoid of soul. The young man who once seemed to pour the entirety of his soul into his songs was somehow stripped of it. The first warning sign is the deadly parentheses on track three – “Half of My Heart” (with Taylor Swift). This album is riddled with the most generic, mindless pop this side of Swift with schmaltz like “All We Ever Do is Say Goodbye” and “War of My Life.” Every dismissive thing my friends said when I defended him had come true. At least on this album, John Mayer has devolved into a complete wuss.
Because the majority of the album is so sickly sweet the few attempts at originality completely fall flat. “Assassin” experiments with a lot of studio tricks if featured on a more mature album might have been viewed as brilliant. Here it just seems weird. The closing track “Friends, Lovers, or Nothing” at least peeks back into the style Mayer fans have come to love, but having to slog through the entire album to get to it, it almost seems like a cruel joke. And if Mayer is the supposed heir to the blues throne, the cover of the legendary “Crossroads” is about as rigid and white a blues cover there ever has been - complete with (shudder) a metronome. A little advice: never pay blues with a metronome. It completely negates the point of blues.
For a coup-de-grace, the two songs he has spinning on the radio, “Who Says” and “Heartbreak Warfare” probably disappoint the most. Listen to the main guitar lick of “Who Says.” Note for note, it’s exactly the same as “Stop This Train” from Continuum. And “Heartbreak Warfare?” At least it’s the best Coldplay song in a while. Speaking of guitar licks – there are none. There are two (arguably three) guitar “solos” on the whole album if you can even call them that. Knowing what Mayer is truly capable of, they’re quarter-hearted, blasé whimpers. And after trumpeting on his website that the entire album would feature Trio members Steve Jordan and Pino Palladino, well, battle pun intended, they are missing in action. It’s an album full of recycled themes, cookie-cutter pop, and little originality.
So is John Mayer capable of that dream crossover album he seemed to tease us with? I really feel he still is. Does he care about lady-fans coming backstage after concerts more than his place in the history of great guitarists and musicians? Battle Studies suggests that’s the case. This album is going to alienate the legions of new fans that grew to love his true musicianship. It’s certainly going to take something incredible to win me back. Whatever woman (or corporate pop bigwig) broke Mayer’s spirit to write this awful album – you certainly broke mine too.
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment