I feel betrayed. Is John Mayer’s Battle Studies really the follow-up to the incredible Continuum? In the liner notes of Mayer’s critically and commercially acclaimed 2007 album, he wrote, “To all the guitar players out there – keep playing. We need you.” It was a call to arms for aspiring guitarists like myself. Now it seems like a slap in the face. Battle Studies is a study in the generic and a plummet into soul-sucking teen pop. The general who made that battle cry just two years ago has gone scampering to the other side.
When Room for Squares was released in 2001, most people just saw the syrupy sweetness of “Your Body is a Wonderland.” I saw something that hadn’t been in mainstream pop for all of my adolescence – a talented musician who could not only play an instrument, but play it extremely well. I insisted to people that there was something special with Mayer when you looked past the radio hits. When I heard “My Stupid Mouth,” “3X5,” “Love Song for No One,” and “St. Patrick’s Day” it inspired me to do something I hadn’t in almost four years – pick up my guitar. I can honestly say if it weren’t for Room for Squares I might never have returned to the guitar. Now I haven’t put it down since. Those four songs I mentioned also directly influenced my songwriting.
For the next six years I continued to insist to everyone that John Mayer was not a wuss. I even defended the “superpop” of 2004’s Heavier Things. I knew he was an incredible guitarist who could also write a great pop song. My theory finally came to fulfillment with the birth of the blistering John Mayer Trio with their raw and shred-filled album, “Try!” in 2006. I felt vindicated.
Whether Mayer could harness that energy into a studio album was realized in Continuum. It remained true to his pop roots, but he injected such maturity and soul into it that even ballads like “Heart of Life” and “Dreaming With a Broken Heart” seemed earnest and deep. Mayer dared to shred on a pop album with his fantastic cover of “Bold as Love” and a perfectly executed solo on “In Repair.” He lit the speakers on fire with the reverb-drenched wail of “Slow Dancing in Burning Room.” He even went way old school with a touch of Ray Charles on “I’m Gonna Find Another You.” And how he built on his hits “Gravity” and “Belief” at live concerts showed his willingness to build on what he had already created. This pop/blues/rock hybrid that Mayer was assembling on Continuum was extremely exciting.
Then the bomb dropped. I waited breathlessly for what Mayer would unleash in his latest album. I had visions of a true crossover album that would make believers out of the remaining Mayer cynics and educate the teenage girls that still make up a huge portion of his fan base that pop can be smart. I logged onto Rhapsody a week before the release where Battle Studies was streaming in its entirety. That’s when John Mayer became my musical Judas.
To Be Continued...
Tuesday, November 17, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment