“And nowwww, the end is neeeear. And so I face the final curtain…”
Frankie’s right boys and girls—the BoSox will not see the playoffs for the first time since 2006. They finish in third place behind the Yanks and the Rays. Hmm, who could have possibly predicted that would happen? I’ll admit, many of my reasons for picking the Sox to slip to third were wrong. First, I have to man up and give a big ol’ apology to Adrian Beltre. I was wrong and the pundits were right—if Beltre played in a smaller park after 11 years in cavernous Dodger Stadium and Safeco Field and played with a supportive team, he would explode. I didn’t believe it, but without Beltre this year, the Sox might have fared even worse. He is the Sox team MVP, no question. He was probably the most entertaining player all year with the most ridiculous home run swings I’ve ever seen.
Of course the real nail in the coffin was the endless injuries. I’m almost glad the Sox didn’t make the playoffs because it just wouldn’t be the same without Pedey and Youk in the lineup. So let’s hand out grades for the year, even for those who didn’t play a full season.
Adrian Beltre: A
As I said before, he’s the team MVP. He was the only one of Theo’s highly questionable offseason contracts to return very good dividends. The only problem is, he will likely use this season to get a huge contract with someone else. Now he knows he can produce in a smaller park. Could he make the Phillies even scarier?
Clay Buchholz: A
Sox fans knew we had found something special when young Clay threw a no-hitter in just his second start of his career. He had a sophomore slump of the worst kind in ’08, but came back nicely in ’09, and clearly jumped to the forefront of AL elite pitchers this year. It’s going to be something special to see what Clay and Jon Lester will do in years to come. Speaking Jonny…
Jon Lester: A-
Lester gets the minus because of his slow start and few inexplicable meltdowns in the second half. Still, Lester will finish with 20 wins and get serious votes for the Cy Young award. His few meltdowns this season are really baffling, but when Lester is on, he is ON.
David Ortiz: A-
PLEASE FORGIVE US PAPI!!! Man, does this guy know how to prove people wrong or what? I guess we just have to expect a slow April from the big man from now on. He is getting up there, but with the Home Run Derby crown under his belt and cracking 30 dingers for the first time since ’07, Papi is clearly still on top of his game. Pay da man!
Daniel Bard: A-
After Papelbon’s horrid 2010 season and how much Bard shined on the big stage, it is clear that he is the closer of the future. I highly doubt Paps will go anywhere this off-season or next season, but Bard is without a doubt the Sox’s opening day closer in 2012.
Victor Martinez: B+
Victor saved a somewhat bland season by absolutely tearing the cover off the ball in August and September, almost singlehandedly saving the Red Sox’s 2010 season. It was too little, too late though. He certainly made his case for a big contract and I think the Sox should give it to him. His days as a catcher are over, I think, and next year could be the Sox’s opening day first baseman with Youk our every day third baseman.
Dustin Pedroia: B+ * (incomplete)
Never hit 3 home runs in a game ever again Pedey! Lil’ Dusty was on his way to serious MVP contention again when the injury bug bit him as well. Such a bummer. It really says something about the season he was having that he only played 75 games and still finished the year eighth on the team in RBI.
Kevin Youkilis: B+ * (incomplete)
Same deal here for the Youkah. What could have been an MVP year ended with injury. He was on the same kind of clip as Pedroia. Sigh.
Darnell McDonald: B+
Where did this guy come from?? McDonald came up time and time again with production the Red Sox so desperately needed in one of the great utility performances in recent memory. It shows the kind of year the Sox had though when he played more than 100 games. Yikes. He may not be with the Sox next year, but I sure hope he gets a good look as an everyday player for the Royals or Indians because he deserves a shot as a team leader.
Terry Francona: B
Slow clap for Tito. This guy endured one of the toughest year’s a manager can go through and still kept his team relevant until the last week of the season. After decades of Sox fans loving to gripe about the manager and firing the manager was the front office’s favorite winter sport, Tito’s job is easily the safest of anyone’s on the Sox for a long time to come. Only some Grady Little moments with pitching changes bring down his grade somewhat.
Marco Scutaro: B
The defense was far from advertised, but he was one of the most clutch players on the Sox, especially in the second half. He had nearly identical offensive production from last year with Toronto – what more can you ask?
J.D. Drew: B-
Drew put up pretty solid numbers with more than 20 dingers, but the average and lack of ability in the clutch still kills me. I can’t wait to see him go (and hopefully be replaced by the incredible Ryan Westmoreland)
Bill Hall: C+
Staggeringly inconsistent on defense and almost as inconsistent on offense. He did put up good home run and RBI numbers, though. Not a great, nor bad season for Hall.
John Lackey: C
The J.D. Drew of pitching, Lackey underwhelmed in every way with the Sox (something I predicted thank you very much). Second on the team in strikeouts do not make up for an ugly 4.47 ERA and a 13-12 record. But we do have him for four more years! Hoorayyyy….ugh.
Tim Wakefield: C
I feel for the guy. I really do. I want him to pass Clemens and Cy Young for the all-time wins. But the elder statesman does not have the stuff anymore. I’d like him around one more year, but that’s it.
Josh Beckett: C-
What a lost season for Beckett. That huge contract couldn’t wait until after the season? Beckett’s downward trend is similar to that of his clone in Lackey. It’s a certainly foggy future for the supposed ace of the Red Sox.
Daisuke Matsuzaka: D+
The 100 million dollar man has worn out his welcome. He is not effective in American baseball and needs to go. The Sox have plenty of prospects in the system and at a much cheaper rate than Dice-K. With Beckett and Lackey taking up so much of the payroll, the Sox should seriously shop the Dice Man this offseason. What a bust.
Jonathan Papelbon: D+
Heart-attack Paps reached the low point of his career this year. Yes, he still collected 37 saves, but he blew a career high 8 and probably cost the Sox the playoffs. An ERA of 10.61 and a WHIP of 2.14 in September just won’t cut it. He’ll still be the Sox closer in 2011, but the Sox should not give him an offer when he’s eligible for free agency for the first time after next season.
Rest of the Bullpen: D
It was a patchwork bullpen to begin with, but with the likes of Scott Atchison out there in key situations, it was ugly. Atchison has no business on a contender, let alone in key situations against the Yankees. Okajima had a lost year too. This is clearly the Sox’s biggest concern to address in the off-season.
Jacoby Ellsbury: F
Maybe I’m being too hard on Ells for being out with the injuries, but he clearly angered a lot of people with his attitude about it. He will need to have an epic year in 2011 to win people back.
Mike Cameron: F
Another signing I shunned and I was right about. Cameron’s age was the biggest question mark and it had everything to do with his dismal and injury-marred season. Hang it up Mike.
Theo Epstein: F
OK Theo, your science experiment year is done. You were dead wrong about being able to statistically predict defensive performance. The Yankees ended up being one of the better defensive teams in the league--but by the supposed precise defensive statistics that should not have happened. Defense is the one part of baseball you can never predict or measure accurately. Go back to what made the Sox good in the first place when you started—getting on base and producing runs. The off-season signings have been getting worse and worse for the front office and Theo needs a rebound year big time.
Free passes: Mike Lowell, Jason Varitek, Daniel Nava, and Ryan Kalish
Lowell deserves a better send-off, but the 2007 World Series MVP will ride off into the sunset as one of the class acts of his era. Varitek was on his way to a bounce-back year, but injuries hampered him too. His days as the Sox’s captain are likely over and I wouldn’t be surprised if he ends up retiring as well. Nava and Kalish are two of the many reasons to be excited about the Red Sox farm system.
Overall Grade for the Sox: C-
“Blah” is the word that comes to mind for the 2010 Red Sox. This grade is largely incomplete because of all the injuries, but most of the guys who played this season were just as I said—blah. The team needs to shore up the bullpen big time, unload some dead weight, and start transitioning to the young guys. With several cogs bound to leave the Rays this off-season, second place should be back within the Sox’s grasp in 2011. If they can figure out how to stay healthy, they should ride right with the Yanks.
No comments:
Post a Comment